The lists below contain films that voters in one poll likes more than the voters in the other poll did. The lists are ranked by the "% difference," which is the absolute value of the difference between the percent of critics' ballots on which a film appeared and the percent of directors' ballots on which a film appeared. For example, if a film appeared on 9.74% of the ballots from people with unknown birth years and 5.31% of ballots from people with known birth years, the % difference would be 4.43%.
Rank |
Title |
Year |
Director |
% Difference |
1 |
Vertigo |
1958 |
Alfred Hitchcock |
6.51% |
2 |
Man with a Movie Camera |
1929 |
Dziga Vertov |
4.80% |
3 |
Mulholland Dr |
2003 |
David Lynch |
2.88% |
4 |
Late Spring |
1949 |
Ozu Yasujirô |
2.86% |
5 |
Battleship Potemkin |
1925 |
Sergei M Eisenstein |
2.68% |
6 |
Searchers, The |
1956 |
John Ford |
2.63% |
7 |
Wild Strawberries |
1957 |
Ingmar Bergman |
2.57% |
8 |
Histoire(s) du cinéma |
1988-2004 |
Jean-Luc Godard |
2.55% |
9 |
In The Mood For Love |
2000 |
Wong Kar Wai |
2.49% |
10 |
argent, L' |
1983 |
Robert Bresson |
2.46% |
11 |
Touki Bouki |
1973 |
Djibril Diop Mambéty |
2.33% |
12 |
Jeanne Dielman, 23 quai du Commerce, 1080 Bruxelles |
1975 |
Chantal Akerman |
2.27% |
13 |
Sunrise |
1927 |
F. W. Murnau |
2.19% |
14 |
Sans Soleil |
1982 |
Chris Marker |
1.80% |
15 |
Citizen Kane |
1941 |
Orson Welles |
1.79% |
16 |
Meshes of the Afternoon |
1943 |
Maya Deren, Alexander Hammid |
1.71% |
17 |
Sherlock Jr |
1924 |
Buster Keaton |
1.69% |
18 |
Passion of Joan of Arc |
1927 |
Carl Theodor Dreyer |
1.65% |
19 |
Breathless |
1960 |
Jean-Luc Godard |
1.64% |
20 |
Playtime |
1967 |
Jacques Tati |
1.63% |
21 |
Performance |
1970 |
Donald Cammell, Nicolas Roeg |
1.58% |
22 |
Colour of Pomegranates, The |
1968 |
Sergei Parajanov |
1.57% |
23 |
North by Northwest |
1959 |
Alfred Hitchcock |
1.54% |
24 |
Sátántangó |
1994 |
Béla Tarr |
1.52% |
25 |
Singin' in the Rain |
1951 |
Stanley Donen, Gene Kelly |
1.47% |
26 |
Jetée, La |
1962 |
Chris Marker |
1.41% |
27 |
Metropolis |
1927 |
Fritz Lang |
1.39% |
28 |
Passenger, The |
1974 |
Michelangelo Antonioni |
1.33% |
29 |
One and a Two, A |
1999 |
Edward Yang |
1.33% |
30 |
Spirit of the Beehive, The |
1973 |
Víctor Erice |
1.31% |
31 |
Rio Bravo |
1958 |
Howard Hawks |
1.30% |
32 |
Blade Runner |
1982 |
Ridley Scott |
1.29% |
33 |
Atalante, L' |
1934 |
Jean Vigo |
1.28% |
34 |
Stalker |
1979 |
Andrei Tarkovsky |
1.23% |
35 |
Out 1 |
1990 |
Jacques Rivette |
1.22% |
36 |
City of Sadness, A |
1989 |
Hsiao-hsien Hou |
1.21% |
37 |
Lady Eve, The |
1941 |
Preston Sturges |
1.20% |
38 |
Brighter Summer Day, A |
1991 |
Edward Yang |
1.18% |
= |
enfants du paradis, Les |
1945 |
Marcel Carné |
1.18% |
40 |
Chinatown |
1974 |
Roman Polanski |
1.18% |
41 |
Leopard, The |
1963 |
Luchino Visconti |
1.17% |
42 |
Règle du jeu, La |
1939 |
Jean Renoir |
1.16% |
43 |
City Lights |
1931 |
Charles Chaplin |
1.13% |
44 |
2001: A Space Odyssey |
1968 |
Stanley Kubrick |
1.11% |
45 |
Colossal Youth |
2006 |
Pedro Costa |
1.11% |
= |
Paris, Texas |
1984 |
Wim Wenders |
1.11% |
= |
Touch of Zen, A |
1969 |
King Hu |
1.11% |
48 |
Do The Right Thing |
1989 |
Spike Lee |
1.08% |
49 |
Life and Death of Colonel Blimp, The |
1943 |
Michael Powell, Emeric Pressburger |
1.07% |
50 |
Sunset Blvd. |
1950 |
Billy Wilder |
1.03% |
51 |
Daisies |
1966 |
Vera Chytilová |
0.98% |
= |
October |
1928 |
Sergei M Eisenstein |
0.98% |
= |
West of the Tracks |
2002 |
Wang Bing |
0.98% |
54 |
Trip to the Moon, A |
1902 |
Georges Méliès |
0.97% |
55 |
Gertrud |
1964 |
Carl Theodor Dreyer |
0.88% |
= |
Journey to Italy |
1954 |
Roberto Rossellini |
0.88% |
57 |
Close-Up |
1989 |
Abbas Kiarostami |
0.87% |
58 |
All That Heaven Allows |
1955 |
Douglas Sirk |
0.86% |
= |
demoiselles de Rochefort, Les |
1967 |
Jacques Demy |
0.86% |
= |
French Cancan |
1955 |
Jean Renoir |
0.86% |
61 |
Shoah |
1985 |
Claude Lanzmann |
0.86% |
62 |
Black Narcissus |
1947 |
Michael Powell, Emeric Pressburger |
0.83% |
= |
Nosferatu |
1922 |
F. W. Murnau |
0.83% |
= |
Red Shoes, The |
1948 |
Michael Powell, Emeric Pressburger |
0.83% |
= |
Spring in a Small Town |
1948 |
Fei Mu |
0.83% |
= |
Three Colours: Blue |
1993 |
Krzysztof Kieslowski |
0.83% |
67 |
Wavelength |
1967 |
Michael Snow |
0.82% |
68 |
Blow Up |
1966 |
Michelangelo Antonioni |
0.82% |
69 |
Beau Travail |
1998 |
Claire Denis |
0.80% |
70 |
General, The |
1926 |
Buster Keaton |
0.75% |
= |
Pather Panchali |
1955 |
Satyajit Ray |
0.75% |
72 |
Affair to Remember, An |
1957 |
Leo McCarey |
0.74% |
= |
India Song |
1975 |
Marguerite Duras |
0.74% |
= |
Matrix, The |
1999 |
Andy Wachowski, Lana Wachowski |
0.74% |
= |
Muriel |
1963 |
Alain Resnais |
0.74% |
= |
Sorrow and the Pity, The |
1969 |
Marcel Ophüls |
0.74% |
77 |
Duck Soup |
1933 |
Leo McCarey |
0.73% |
= |
House is Black, The |
1962 |
Forough Farrokhzad |
0.73% |
= |
I Know Where I'm Going! |
1945 |
Michael Powell, Emeric Pressburger |
0.73% |
= |
Kings of the Road |
1976 |
Wim Wenders |
0.73% |
81 |
Earth |
1930 |
Aleksandr Dovzhenko |
0.72% |
= |
In a Lonely Place |
1950 |
Nicholas Ray |
0.72% |
= |
Notorious |
1946 |
Alfred Hitchcock |
0.72% |
= |
Sweet Smell of Success |
1957 |
Alexander Mackendrick |
0.72% |
= |
Tabu |
1931 |
F. W. Murnau |
0.72% |
86 |
Canterbury Tale, A |
1944 |
Michael Powell, Emeric Pressburger |
0.71% |
= |
Werckmeister Harmonies, The |
2000 |
Béla Tarr |
0.71% |
88 |
Ivan the Terrible |
1945 |
Sergei M Eisenstein |
0.70% |
= |
Madame de… |
1953 |
Max Ophüls |
0.70% |
= |
Tropical Malady |
2004 |
Apichatpong Weerasethakul |
0.70% |
91 |
Greed |
1925 |
Erich von Stroheim |
0.69% |
92 |
Casablanca |
1942 |
Michael Curtiz |
0.68% |
= |
chien andalou, Un |
1928 |
Luis Buñuel |
0.68% |
94 |
Nashville |
1975 |
Robert Altman |
0.67% |
95 |
Aguaespejo granadino |
1955 |
José Val del Omar |
0.62% |
= |
Barton Fink |
1991 |
Joel & Ethan Coen |
0.62% |
= |
Hatari! |
1961 |
Howard Hawks |
0.62% |
= |
Headless Woman, The |
2008 |
Lucrecia Martel |
0.62% |
= |
In Vanda's Room |
2000 |
Pedro Costa |
0.62% |
= |
Lola Montès |
1955 |
Max Ophüls |
0.62% |
= |
Platform |
2000 |
Jia Zhang Ke |
0.62% |
= |
Port of Shadows |
1938 |
Marcel Carné |
0.62% |
= |
Purple Rose of Cairo, The |
1985 |
Woody Allen |
0.62% |
= |
Scenes from a Marriage |
1995 |
Ingmar Bergman |
0.62% |
= |
Seasons of the Year, The |
1975 |
Artavazd Pelechian |
0.62% |
= |
The Tiger of Eschnapur/The Indian Tomb |
1958 |
Fritz Lang |
0.62% |
= |
Winter Light |
1972 |
Ingmar Bergman |
0.62% |
108 |
Autumn Afternoon, An |
1962 |
Ozu Yasujirô |
0.61% |
= |
Band Wagon, The |
1953 |
Vincente Minnelli |
0.61% |
= |
How Green Was My Valley |
1941 |
John Ford |
0.61% |
= |
Johnny Guitar |
1954 |
Nicholas Ray |
0.61% |
= |
Shadows of Our Forgotten Ancestors |
1964 |
Sergei Parajanov |
0.61% |
= |
Throne of Blood |
1957 |
Akira Kurosawa |
0.61% |
= |
WALL-E |
2008 |
Andrew Stanton |
0.61% |
= |
World of Apu, The |
1958 |
Satyajit Ray |
0.61% |
116 |
His Girl Friday |
1939 |
Howard Hawks |
0.60% |
= |
Russian Ark |
2002 |
Aleksandr Sokurov |
0.60% |
= |
Spirited Away |
2001 |
Miyazaki Hayao |
0.60% |
119 |
Brief Encounter |
1945 |
David Lean |
0.59% |
= |
Solaris |
1972 |
Andrei Tarkovsky |
0.59% |
121 |
Imitation of Life |
1959 |
Douglas Sirk |
0.57% |
= |
Matter of Life and Death, A |
1946 |
Michael Powell, Emeric Pressburger |
0.57% |
= |
Partie de campagne |
1936 |
Jean Renoir |
0.57% |
124 |
Maman et la putain, La |
1973 |
Jean Eustache |
0.53% |
125 |
Pierrot le Fou |
1965 |
Jean-Luc Godard |
0.51% |
Rank |
Title |
Year |
Director |
% Difference |
1 |
Bicycle Thieves, The |
1948 |
Vittorio de Sica |
3.23% |
2 |
strada, La |
1954 |
Federico Fellini |
3.22% |
3 |
Raging Bull |
1980 |
Martin Scorsese |
3.19% |
4 |
Persona |
1966 |
Ingmar Bergman |
2.74% |
5 |
Fanny and Alexander |
1984 |
Ingmar Bergman |
2.65% |
6 |
Taxi Driver |
1976 |
Martin Scorsese |
2.49% |
7 |
argent, L' |
1928 |
Marcel L'Herbier |
2.40% |
8 |
Hour of the Wolf |
1968 |
Ingmar Bergman |
2.31% |
= |
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest |
1975 |
Milos Forman |
2.31% |
10 |
Apartment, The |
1960 |
Billy Wilder |
2.22% |
11 |
Barry Lyndon |
1975 |
Stanley Kubrick |
2.15% |
12 |
Seven Samurai |
1954 |
Akira Kurosawa |
1.98% |
13 |
Gospel According to St Matthew, The |
1964 |
Pier Paolo Pasolini |
1.95% |
14 |
Mirror |
1974 |
Andrei Tarkovsky |
1.87% |
15 |
Lawrence of Arabia |
1962 |
David Lean |
1.86% |
16 |
Aguirre, Wrath of God |
1972 |
Werner Herzog |
1.85% |
17 |
grande illusion, La |
1937 |
Jean Renoir |
1.74% |
18 |
Killing of a Chinese Bookie, The |
1976 |
John Cassavetes |
1.67% |
19 |
Man Escaped, A |
1956 |
Robert Bresson |
1.62% |
20 |
Once Upon a Time in the West |
1968 |
Sergio Leone |
1.61% |
21 |
Vivre Sa Vie |
1962 |
Jean-Luc Godard |
1.58% |
22 |
Godfather: Part II, The |
1974 |
Francis Ford Coppola |
1.54% |
23 |
dolce vita, La |
1960 |
Federico Fellini |
1.53% |
24 |
Godfather: Part I, The |
1972 |
Francis Ford Coppola |
1.48% |
25 |
Come And See |
1985 |
Elem Klimov |
1.46% |
= |
Seventh Seal, The |
1957 |
Ingmar Bergman |
1.46% |
27 |
Nights of Cabiria |
1957 |
Federico Fellini |
1.42% |
28 |
Boudu Saved from Drowning |
1932 |
Jean Renoir |
1.41% |
= |
Cranes are Flying, The |
1957 |
Mikhail Kalatozov |
1.41% |
30 |
Tokyo Story |
1953 |
Ozu Yasujirô |
1.35% |
31 |
Andrei Rublev |
1966 |
Andrei Tarkovsky |
1.33% |
32 |
Hiroshima Mon Amour |
1959 |
Alain Resnais |
1.31% |
= |
To Be or Not To Be |
1942 |
Ernst Lubitsch |
1.31% |
34 |
Deer Hunter, The |
1977 |
Michael Cimino |
1.29% |
= |
Umberto D |
1952 |
Vittorio de Sica |
1.29% |
36 |
Enigma of Kaspar Hauser, The |
1974 |
Werner Herzog |
1.28% |
37 |
Au Hasard Balthazar |
1966 |
Robert Bresson |
1.21% |
38 |
Goodfellas |
1990 |
Martin Scorsese |
1.20% |
39 |
Ikiru |
1952 |
Akira Kurosawa |
1.19% |
40 |
Faces |
1968 |
John Cassavetes |
1.18% |
= |
Kes |
1969 |
Ken Loach |
1.18% |
42 |
It's a Wonderful Life |
1947 |
Frank Capra |
1.17% |
= |
Zero de Conduite |
1933 |
Jean Vigo |
1.17% |
44 |
Nanook of the North |
1922 |
Robert J. Flaherty |
1.16% |
45 |
Alphaville |
1965 |
Jean-Luc Godard |
1.15% |
= |
Songs from the Second Floor |
2000 |
Roy Andersson |
1.15% |
= |
Woman of the Dunes |
1964 |
Teshigahara Hiroshi |
1.15% |
48 |
Viridiana |
1961 |
Luis Buñuel |
1.09% |
49 |
Good, the Bad and the Ugly, The |
1966 |
Sergio Leone |
1.06% |
= |
There Will Be Blood |
2007 |
Paul Thomas Anderson |
1.06% |
51 |
Crimes and Misdemeanors |
1989 |
Woody Allen |
1.04% |
= |
Paths of Glory |
1957 |
Stanley Kubrick |
1.04% |
53 |
Koyaanisqatsi |
1983 |
Godfrey Reggio |
1.03% |
54 |
Nazarín |
1958 |
Luis Buñuel |
1.02% |
= |
Veronika Voss |
1982 |
Rainer Werner Fassbinder |
1.02% |
56 |
Modern Times |
1936 |
Charles Chaplin |
1.01% |
57 |
Conformist, The |
1970 |
Bernardo Bertolucci |
0.96% |
58 |
olvidados, Los |
1950 |
Luis Buñuel |
0.95% |
59 |
Mouchette |
1966 |
Robert Bresson |
0.94% |
60 |
Manhattan |
1979 |
Woody Allen |
0.92% |
61 |
Ashes and Diamonds |
1958 |
Andrzej Wajda |
0.92% |
= |
Thin Blue Line, The |
1989 |
Errol Morris |
0.92% |
63 |
Dog Day Afternoon |
1975 |
Sidney Lumet |
0.90% |
= |
Elephant |
1989 |
Alan Clarke |
0.90% |
= |
On The Waterfront |
1954 |
Elia Kazan |
0.90% |
66 |
eclisse, L' |
1962 |
Michelangelo Antonioni |
0.86% |
67 |
8½ |
1963 |
Federico Fellini |
0.82% |
68 |
400 Blows, The |
1959 |
François Truffaut |
0.81% |
69 |
E.T. |
1982 |
Steven Spielberg |
0.80% |
= |
Husbands |
1970 |
John Cassavetes |
0.80% |
71 |
mépris, Le |
1963 |
Jean-Luc Godard |
0.80% |
72 |
Melancholia |
2011 |
Lars von Trier |
0.79% |
= |
My Darling Clementine |
1946 |
John Ford |
0.79% |
74 |
Festen |
1998 |
Thomas Vinterberg |
0.78% |
75 |
Devils, The |
1971 |
Ken Russell |
0.77% |
= |
Executioner, The |
1963 |
Luis García Berlanga |
0.77% |
= |
Graduate, The |
1967 |
Mike Nichols |
0.77% |
= |
Lola |
1961 |
Jacques Demy |
0.77% |
= |
Orphée |
1950 |
Jean Cocteau |
0.77% |
= |
Round-Up, The |
1966 |
Miklos Jancso |
0.77% |
= |
Sacrifice, The |
1986 |
Andrei Tarkovsky |
0.77% |
= |
Short Film About Killing, A |
1987 |
Krzysztof Kieslowski |
0.77% |
= |
Silence, The |
1963 |
Ingmar Bergman |
0.77% |
= |
Tenant, The |
1976 |
Roman Polanski |
0.77% |
85 |
All That Jazz |
1979 |
Bob Fosse |
0.77% |
= |
Asphalt Jungle, The |
1950 |
John Huston |
0.77% |
= |
Ben-Hur |
1959 |
William Wyler |
0.77% |
= |
City of God |
2002 |
Fernando Meirelles |
0.77% |
= |
Deuxième Souffle, Le |
1966 |
Jean-Pierre Melville |
0.77% |
= |
humanité, L' |
1999 |
Bruno Dumont |
0.77% |
= |
Man on Wire |
2007 |
James Marsh |
0.77% |
= |
Midnight Cowboy |
1969 |
John Schlesinger |
0.77% |
= |
Misfits, The |
1961 |
John Huston |
0.77% |
= |
Network |
1976 |
Sidney Lumet |
0.77% |
= |
One, Two, Three |
1961 |
Billy Wilder |
0.77% |
= |
Scarlet Empress, The |
1934 |
Josef von Sternberg |
0.77% |
= |
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs |
1937 |
David Hand et al |
0.77% |
= |
Story of Qiu Ju, The |
1992 |
Zhang Yimou |
0.77% |
= |
Strangers on a Train |
1951 |
Alfred Hitchcock |
0.77% |
= |
Tootsie |
1982 |
Sydney Pollack |
0.77% |
101 |
Third Man, The |
1949 |
Carol Reed |
0.72% |
102 |
Jules et Jim |
1962 |
François Truffaut |
0.69% |
103 |
Napoleon |
1927 |
Abel Gance |
0.68% |
104 |
I am Cuba |
1964 |
Mikhail Kalatozov |
0.67% |
= |
Jaws |
1975 |
Steven Spielberg |
0.67% |
= |
Rocco and his Brothers |
1960 |
Luchino Visconti |
0.67% |
107 |
notte, La |
1961 |
Michelangelo Antonioni |
0.66% |
= |
Pandora's Box |
1928 |
G W Pabst |
0.66% |
= |
Three Colours: Red |
1994 |
Krzysztof Kieslowski |
0.66% |
110 |
Eyes Without a Face |
1960 |
Georges Franju |
0.65% |
= |
Grido, Il |
1957 |
Michelangelo Antonioni |
0.65% |
= |
Kid, The |
1921 |
Charles Chaplin |
0.65% |
= |
Last Picture Show, The |
1971 |
Peter Bogdanovich |
0.65% |
= |
Stagecoach |
1939 |
John Ford |
0.65% |
= |
Underground |
1995 |
Emir Kusturica |
0.65% |
116 |
4 months, 3 weeks and 2 days |
2007 |
Cristian Mungiu |
0.64% |
= |
Bad Sleep Well, The |
1960 |
Akira Kurosawa |
0.64% |
= |
Brazil |
1985 |
Terry Gilliam |
0.64% |
= |
Butch Cassidy and The Sundance Kid |
1969 |
George Roy Hill |
0.64% |
= |
Dodeskaden |
1970 |
Akira Kurosawa |
0.64% |
= |
Flower of My Secret, The |
1995 |
Pedro Almodóvar |
0.64% |
= |
French Connection, The |
1971 |
William Friedkin |
0.64% |
= |
Funny Games |
1997 |
Michael Haneke |
0.64% |
= |
Kiss Me Deadly |
1955 |
Robert Aldrich |
0.64% |
= |
Maltese Falcon, The |
1941 |
John Huston |
0.64% |
= |
Raise the Red Lantern |
1991 |
Zhang Yimou |
0.64% |
= |
Sound of Music, The |
1965 |
Robert Wise |
0.64% |
= |
To Kill a Mockingbird |
1962 |
Robert Mulligan |
0.64% |
129 |
Some Like It Hot |
1959 |
Billy Wilder |
0.64% |
130 |
Scarface |
1932 |
Howard Hawks |
0.63% |
= |
Still Life |
1974 |
Sohrab Shahid Saless |
0.63% |
132 |
Touch of Evil |
1958 |
Orson Welles |
0.63% |
133 |
Ugetsu Monogatari |
1953 |
Mizoguchi Kenji |
0.62% |
134 |
M |
1931 |
Fritz Lang |
0.61% |
135 |
Badlands |
1973 |
Terrence Malick |
0.56% |
= |
Letter From an Unknown Woman |
1948 |
Max Ophüls |
0.56% |
137 |
Opening Night |
1977 |
John Cassavetes |
0.54% |
= |
Piano, The |
1992 |
Jane Campion |
0.54% |
139 |
Magnolia |
1999 |
Paul Thomas Anderson |
0.53% |
= |
Rosetta |
1999 |
Jean-Pierre Dardenne, Luc Dardenne |
0.53% |
141 |
Au Revoir les enfants |
1987 |
Louis Malle |
0.52% |
= |
Bonnie and Clyde |
1967 |
Arthur Penn |
0.52% |
= |
cercle rouge, Le |
1970 |
Jean-Pierre Melville |
0.52% |
= |
Dersu Uzala |
1975 |
Akira Kurosawa |
0.52% |
= |
Down By Law |
1986 |
Jim Jarmusch |
0.52% |
= |
Flaming Creatures |
1963 |
Jack Smith |
0.52% |
= |
Holy Mountain, The |
1973 |
Alejandro Jodorowsky |
0.52% |
= |
Kagemusha |
1980 |
Akira Kurosawa |
0.52% |
= |
Lusty Men, The |
1952 |
Nicholas Ray |
0.52% |
= |
Picnic At Hanging Rock |
1975 |
Peter Weir |
0.52% |
= |
This Is Spinal Tap |
1983 |
Rob Reiner |
0.52% |
= |
Treasure of Sierra Madre, The |
1947 |
John Huston |
0.52% |