| Rank | Title | Year | Director(s) | Overall Rank |
| 1 | Psycho | 1960 | Alfred Hitchcock | 7 |
| 2 | Alien | 1979 | Ridley Scott | 38 |
| 3 | King Kong | 1933 | Merian C. Cooper and Ernest B. Schoedsack | 47 |
| 4 | The Exorcist | 1973 | William Friedkin | 76 |
| 5 | The Shining | 1980 | Stanley Kubrick | 87 |
| 6 | Nosferatu | 1922 | F.W. Murnau | 105 |
| 7 | Bride of Frankenstein | 1935 | James Whale | 121 |
| 8 | Halloween | 1978 | John Carpenter | 131 |
| 9 | Frankenstein | 1931 | James Whale | 137 |
| 10 | Night of the Living Dead | 1968 | George A. Romero | 139 |
| 11 | Don't Look Now | 1973 | Nicolas Roeg | 162 |
| 12 | Invasion of the Body Snatchers | 1956 | Don Siegel | 180 |
| 13 | Rosemary's Baby | 1968 | Roman Polanski | 193 |
| 14 | The Thing | 1982 | John Carpenter | 210 |
| 15 | Dawn of the Dead | 1978 | George A. Romero | 216 |
| 16 | The Wicker Man | 1973 | Robin Hardy | 218 |
| 17 | The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari | 1920 | Robert Wiene | 223 |
| 18 | The Texas Chain Saw Massacre | 1974 | Tobe Hooper | 233 |
| 19 | The Birds | 1963 | Alfred Hitchcock | 262 |
| 20 | Carrie | 1976 | Brian De Palma | 269 |
| 21 | Eraserhead | 1976 | David Lynch | 280 |
| 22 | The Blair Witch Project | 1999 | Daniel Myrick and Eduardo Sánchez | 283 |
| 23 | Freaks | 1932 | Tod Browning | 289 |
| 24 | Diabolique | 1955 | Henri-Georges Clouzot | 294 |
| 25 | Scream | 1996 | Wes Craven | 324 |
| 26 | Suspiria | 1977 | Dario Argento | 327 |
| 27 | A Nightmare on Elm Street | 1984 | Wes Craven | 345 |
| 28 | The Fly | 1986 | David Cronenberg | 349 |
| 29 | Repulsion | 1965 | Roman Polanski | 350 |
| 30 | Evil Dead II | 1987 | Sam Raimi | 359 |
| 31 | Shaun of the Dead | 2004 | Edgar Wright | 394 |
| 32 | Dracula | 1931 | Tod Browning | 399 |
| 33 | The Evil Dead | 1981 | Sam Raimi | 404 |
| 34 | The Haunting | 1963 | Robert Wise | 418 |
| 35 | An American Werewolf in London | 1981 | John Landis | 438 |
| 36 | Cat People | 1942 | Jacques Tourneur | 458 |
| 37 | Pink Flamingos | 1972 | John Waters | 500 |
| 38 | The Thing from Another World | 1951 | Christian Nyby | 513 |
| 39 | Picnic at Hanging Rock | 1975 | Peter Weir | 567 |
| 40 | The Innocents | 1961 | Jack Clayton | 583 |
| 41 | The Phantom of the Opera | 1925 | Rupert Julian | 627 |
| 42 | Dead of Night | 1945 | Alberto Cavalcanti, Charles Crichton, Basil Dearden, and Robert Hamer | 640 |
| 43 | 28 Days Later… | 2002 | Danny Boyle | 648 |
| 44 | Eyes without a Face | 1960 | Georges Franju | 662 |
| 45 | What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? | 1962 | Robert Aldrich | 682 |
| 46 | Poltergeist | 1982 | Tobe Hooper | 691 |
| 47 | The War of the Worlds | 1953 | Byron Haskin | 711 |
| 48 | Horror of Dracula | 1958 | Terence Fisher | 718 |
| 49 | The Invisible Man | 1933 | James Whale | 731 |
| 50 | The Omen | 1976 | Richard Donner | 739 |
| 51 | The Audition | 1999 | Takashi Miike | 802 |
| 52 | Re-Animator | 1985 | Stuart Gordon | 812 |
| 53 | Carnival of Souls | 1962 | Herk Harvey | 824 |
| 54 | Curse of the Demon | 1957 | Jacques Tourneur | 833 |
| 55 | Near Dark | 1987 | Kathryn Bigelow | 834 |
| 56 | Godzilla | 1954 | Ishirô Honda | 847 |
| 57 | The Mummy | 1932 | Karl Freund | 852 |
| 58 | Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein | 1948 | Charles Barton | 857 |
| 59 | Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde | 1931 | Rouben Mamoulian | 874 |
| 60 | I Walked with a Zombie | 1943 | Jacques Tourneur | 883 |
| 61 | Invasion of the Body Snatchers | 1978 | Philip Kaufman | 889 |
| 62 | Ring | 1998 | Hideo Nakata | 921 |
| 63 | Jacob's Ladder | 1990 | Adrian Lyne | 924 |
| 64 | Vampyr | 1932 | Carl Theodor Dreyer | 929 |
| 65 | The Devil's Backbone | 2001 | Guillermo del Toro | 952 |
| 66 | Braindead | 1992 | Peter Jackson | 969 |
| 67 | The Wolf Man | 1941 | George Waggner | 985 |
| 68 | Black Sunday | 1960 | Mario Bava | 995 |
| 69 | Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer | 1986 | John McNaughton | 1010 |
| 70 | The Black Cat | 1934 | Edgar G. Ulmer | 1046 |
| 71 | Nosferatu the Vampyre | 1979 | Werner Herzog | 1047 |
| 72 | Hellraiser | 1987 | Clive Barker | 1070 |
| 73 | Gremlins | 1984 | Joe Dante | 1152 |
| 74 | Friday the 13th | 1980 | Sean S. Cunningham | 1156 |
| 75 | From Dusk Till Dawn | 1996 | Robert Rodriguez | 1222 |
| 76 | Candyman | 1992 | Bernard Rose | 1240 |
| 77 | Plan 9 from Outer Space | 1958 | Edward D. Wood Jr. | 1318 |
| 78 | Bram Stoker's Dracula | 1992 | Francis Ford Coppola | 1320 |
| 79 | The Old Dark House | 1932 | James Whale | 1321 |
| 80 | Lost Highway | 1997 | David Lynch | 1322 |
| 81 | Onibaba | 1964 | Kaneto Shindô | 1324 |
| 82 | Them! | 1954 | Gordon Douglas | 1329 |
| 83 | Angel Heart | 1987 | Alan Parker | 1353 |
| 84 | Army of Darkness | 1992 | Sam Raimi | 1360 |
| 85 | Faust | 1926 | F.W. Murnau | 1375 |
| 86 | The Ring | 2002 | Gore Verbinski | 1422 |
| 87 | Creature from the Black Lagoon | 1954 | Jack Arnold | 1462 |
| 88 | Village of the Damned | 1960 | Wolf Rilla | 1465 |
| 89 | Hour of the Wolf | 1968 | Ingmar Bergman | 1473 |
| 90 | Quatermass and the Pit | 1967 | Roy Ward Baker | 1478 |
| 91 | Saw | 2004 | James Wan | 1534 |
| 92 | Day of the Dead | 1985 | George A. Romero | 1571 |
| 93 | The Brood | 1979 | David Cronenberg | 1577 |
| 94 | Dawn of the Dead | 2004 | Zack Snyder | 1587 |
| 95 | The Last House on the Left | 1972 | Wes Craven | 1591 |
| 96 | Altered States | 1980 | Ken Russell | 1644 |
| 97 | The Descent | 2005 | Neil Marshall | 1648 |
| 98 | Female Trouble | 1974 | John Waters | 1649 |
| 99 | The Lost Boys | 1987 | Joel Schumacher | 1663 |
| 100 | Little Shop of Horrors | 1986 | Frank Oz | 1668 |
| 101 | The Howling | 1981 | Joe Dante | 1698 |
| 102 | Blade | 1998 | Stephen Norrington | 1700 |
| 103 | The Lost World | 1925 | Harry O. Hoyt | 1715 |
| 104 | Scream 2 | 1997 | Wes Craven | 1726 |
| 105 | The Devils | 1971 | Ken Russell | 1729 |
| 106 | The Hills Have Eyes | 1977 | Wes Craven | 1736 |
| 107 | House of Wax | 1953 | André De Toth | 1746 |
| 108 | The Hunger | 1983 | Tony Scott | 1777 |
| 109 | Black Christmas | 1974 | Bob Clark | 1782 |
| 110 | Cube | 1997 | Vincenzo Natali | 1813 |
| 111 | Martin | 1977 | George A. Romero | 1826 |
| 112 | Fright Night | 1985 | Tom Holland | 1840 |
| 113 | Cannibal Holocaust | 1980 | Ruggero Deodato | 1857 |
| 114 | Island of Lost Souls | 1932 | Erle C. Kenton | 1877 |
| 115 | Häxan: Witchcraft through the Ages | 1922 | Benjamin Christensen | 1887 |
| 116 | Bubba Ho-Tep | 2002 | Don Coscarelli | 1905 |
| 117 | Deep Red | 1975 | Dario Argento | 1906 |
| 118 | Invaders from Mars | 1953 | William Cameron Menzies | 1930 |
| 119 | The Kingdom | 1994 | Morten Arnfred and Lars von Trier | 1960 |
| 120 | The Testament of Dr. Mabuse | 1933 | Fritz Lang | 1964 |
| 121 | The Curse of Frankenstein | 1957 | Terence Fisher | 1999 |
| 122 | Shivers | 1975 | David Cronenberg | 2019 |
| 123 | Phantom of the Paradise | 1974 | Brian De Palma | 2045 |
| 124 | The Fog | 1980 | John Carpenter | 2047 |
| 125 | Phantasm | 1979 | Don Coscarelli | 2048 |
| 126 | The Golem | 1920 | Carl Boese and Paul Wegener | 2051 |
| 127 | High Tension | 2003 | Alexandre Aja | 2083 |
| 128 | The Unknown | 1927 | Tod Browning | 2141 |
| 129 | The Masque of the Red Death | 1964 | Roger Corman | 2161 |
| 130 | Son of Frankenstein | 1939 | Rowland V. Lee | 2172 |
| 131 | They Live | 1988 | John Carpenter | 2189 |
| 132 | The Fly | 1958 | Kurt Neumann | 2198 |
| 133 | Hush... Hush, Sweet Charlotte | 1964 | Robert Aldrich | 2230 |
| 134 | I Spit on Your Grave | 1978 | Meir Zarchi | 2249 |
| 135 | The Hidden | 1987 | Jack Sholder | 2268 |
| 136 | Blood Feast | 1963 | Herschell Gordon Lewis | 2271 |
| 137 | The Host | 2006 | Joon-ho Bong | 2276 |
| 138 | Pit and the Pendulum | 1961 | Roger Corman | 2281 |
| 139 | The Toxic Avenger | 1984 | Michael Herz and Lloyd Kaufman | 2287 |
| 140 | The Curse of the Cat People | 1944 | Robert Wise and Gunther von Fritsch | 2294 |
| 141 | Sisters | 1973 | Brian De Palma | 2299 |
| 142 | The Hound of the Baskervilles | 1939 | Sidney Lanfield | 2301 |
| 143 | Tremors | 1990 | Ron Underwood | 2309 |
| 144 | The Changeling | 1980 | Peter Medak | 2335 |
| 145 | The Stepfather | 1987 | Joseph Ruben | 2339 |
| 146 | Event Horizon | 1997 | Paul W.S. Anderson | 2347 |