| Rank | Title | Year | Director(s) | Overall Rank |
| 1 | Casablanca | 1942 | Michael Curtiz | 5 |
| 2 | Citizen Kane | 1941 | Orson Welles | 11 |
| 3 | The Third Man | 1949 | Carol Reed | 42 |
| 4 | It's a Wonderful Life | 1946 | Frank Capra | 46 |
| 5 | Double Indemnity | 1944 | Billy Wilder | 51 |
| 6 | The Bicycle Thief | 1948 | Vittorio De Sica | 69 |
| 7 | The Maltese Falcon | 1941 | John Huston | 81 |
| 8 | His Girl Friday | 1940 | Howard Hawks | 98 |
| 9 | The Philadelphia Story | 1940 | George Cukor | 126 |
| 10 | The Treasure of the Sierra Madre | 1948 | John Huston | 142 |
| 11 | Notorious | 1946 | Alfred Hitchcock | 148 |
| 12 | The Red Shoes | 1948 | Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger | 150 |
| 13 | The Best Years of Our Lives | 1946 | William Wyler | 200 |
| 14 | Beauty and the Beast | 1946 | Jean Cocteau | 201 |
| 15 | Brief Encounter | 1945 | David Lean | 211 |
| 16 | The Big Sleep | 1946 | Howard Hawks | 215 |
| 17 | Children of Paradise | 1945 | Marcel Carné | 216 |
| 18 | The Great Dictator | 1940 | Charles Chaplin | 222 |
| 19 | Pinocchio | 1940 | Hamilton Luske and Ben Sharpsteen | 224 |
| 20 | Fantasia | 1940 | James Algar, Samuel Armstrong, Ford Beebe Jr., Norman Ferguson, David Hand, Jim Handley, T. Hee, Wilfred Jackson, Hamilton Luske, Bill Roberts, Paul Satterfield, and Ben Sharpsteen | 229 |
| 21 | The Lady Eve | 1941 | Preston Sturges | 239 |
| 22 | To Be or Not to Be | 1942 | Ernst Lubitsch | 251 |
| 23 | The Shop around the Corner | 1940 | Ernst Lubitsch | 260 |
| 24 | The Grapes of Wrath | 1940 | John Ford | 273 |
| 25 | Meet Me in St. Louis | 1944 | Vincente Minnelli | 284 |
| 26 | Rebecca | 1940 | Alfred Hitchcock | 311 |
| 27 | A Matter of Life and Death | 1946 | Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger | 316 |
| 28 | Red River | 1948 | Howard Hawks | 319 |
| 29 | Bambi | 1942 | David Hand | 342 |
| 30 | Kind Hearts and Coronets | 1949 | Robert Hamer | 345 |
| 31 | Rome, Open City | 1945 | Roberto Rossellini | 360 |
| 32 | Sullivan's Travels | 1941 | Preston Sturges | 389 |
| 33 | The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp | 1943 | Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger | 394 |
| 34 | Laura | 1944 | Otto Preminger | 408 |
| 35 | Shadow of a Doubt | 1943 | Alfred Hitchcock | 425 |
| 36 | Cat People | 1942 | Jacques Tourneur | 435 |
| 37 | Black Narcissus | 1947 | Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger | 446 |
| 38 | White Heat | 1949 | Raoul Walsh | 447 |
| 39 | My Darling Clementine | 1946 | John Ford | 450 |
| 40 | Mildred Pierce | 1945 | Michael Curtiz | 454 |
| 41 | The Magnificent Ambersons | 1942 | Orson Welles | 456 |
| 42 | Out of the Past | 1947 | Jacques Tourneur | 461 |
| 43 | Dumbo | 1941 | Ben Sharpsteen | 482 |
| 44 | Great Expectations | 1946 | David Lean | 539 |
| 45 | Late Spring | 1949 | Yasujirô Ozu | 593 |
| 46 | Arsenic and Old Lace | 1944 | Frank Capra | 656 |
| 47 | The Ox-Bow Incident | 1942 | William A. Wellman | 701 |
| 48 | Dead of Night | 1945 | Alberto Cavalcanti, Charles Crichton, Basil Dearden, and Robert Hamer | 787 |
| 49 | Letter from an Unknown Woman | 1948 | Max Ophüls | 793 |
| 50 | Day of Wrath | 1943 | Carl Theodor Dreyer | 799 |
| 51 | Miracle on 34th Street | 1947 | George Seaton | 807 |
| 52 | Yankee Doodle Dandy | 1942 | Michael Curtiz | 820 |
| 53 | Meshes of the Afternoon | 1943 | Maya Deren and Alexander Hammid | 823 |
| 54 | Rope | 1948 | Alfred Hitchcock | 856 |
| 55 | Adam's Rib | 1949 | George Cukor | 880 |
| 56 | The Lost Weekend | 1945 | Billy Wilder | 892 |
| 57 | How Green Was My Valley | 1941 | John Ford | 895 |
| 58 | 'I Know Where I'm Going!' | 1945 | Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger | 903 |
| 59 | To Have and Have Not | 1944 | Howard Hawks | 907 |
| 60 | I Walked with a Zombie | 1943 | Jacques Tourneur | 960 |
| 61 | Ivan the Terrible | 1944 | Sergei Eisenstein | 987 |
| 62 | Now, Voyager | 1942 | Irving Rapper | 1012 |
| 63 | She Wore a Yellow Ribbon | 1949 | John Ford | 1013 |
| 64 | On the Town | 1949 | Stanley Donen and Gene Kelly | 1023 |
| 65 | The Wolf Man | 1941 | George Waggner | 1047 |
| 66 | Sergeant York | 1941 | Howard Hawks | 1056 |
| 67 | The Lady from Shanghai | 1947 | Orson Welles | 1074 |
| 68 | Twelve O'Clock High | 1949 | Henry King | 1094 |
| 69 | The Postman Always Rings Twice | 1946 | Tay Garnett | 1112 |
| 70 | Fort Apache | 1948 | John Ford | 1118 |
| 71 | The Palm Beach Story | 1942 | Preston Sturges | 1119 |
| 72 | Paisan | 1946 | Roberto Rossellini | 1120 |
| 73 | Gilda | 1946 | Charles Vidor | 1139 |
| 74 | The Killers | 1946 | Robert Siodmak | 1207 |
| 75 | The Pride of the Yankees | 1942 | Sam Wood | 1234 |
| 76 | Detour | 1945 | Edgar G. Ulmer | 1271 |
| 77 | Gaslight | 1944 | George Cukor | 1280 |
| 78 | Force of Evil | 1948 | Abraham Polonsky | 1354 |
| 79 | The Thief of Bagdad | 1940 | Ludwig Berger, Michael Powell, and Tim Whelan | 1359 |
| 80 | The Bank Dick | 1940 | Edward F. Cline | 1383 |
| 81 | National Velvet | 1944 | Clarence Brown | 1388 |
| 82 | They Live by Night | 1948 | Nicholas Ray | 1472 |
| 83 | Key Largo | 1948 | John Huston | 1486 |
| 84 | Odd Man Out | 1947 | Carol Reed | 1487 |
| 85 | Henry V | 1944 | Laurence Olivier | 1503 |
| 86 | Mrs. Miniver | 1942 | William Wyler | 1546 |
| 87 | The Heiress | 1949 | William Wyler | 1557 |
| 88 | Duel in the Sun | 1946 | King Vidor | 1564 |
| 89 | A Day in the Country | 1946 | Jean Renoir | 1625 |
| 90 | They Were Expendable | 1945 | John Ford | 1642 |
| 91 | Monsieur Verdoux | 1947 | Charles Chaplin | 1658 |
| 92 | The Fallen Idol | 1948 | Carol Reed | 1722 |
| 93 | Ossessione | 1943 | Luchino Visconti | 1731 |
| 94 | The Ghost and Mrs. Muir | 1947 | Joseph L. Mankiewicz | 1791 |
| 95 | The Set-Up | 1949 | Robert Wise | 1801 |
| 96 | Foreign Correspondent | 1940 | Alfred Hitchcock | 1813 |
| 97 | The Miracle of Morgan's Creek | 1943 | Preston Sturges | 1843 |
| 98 | Nightmare Alley | 1947 | Edmund Goulding | 1844 |
| 99 | Murder, My Sweet | 1944 | Edward Dmytryk | 1855 |
| 100 | Went the Day Well? | 1942 | Alberto Cavalcanti | 1895 |
| 101 | Germany, Year Zero | 1948 | Roberto Rossellini | 1912 |
| 102 | Battleground | 1949 | William A. Wellman | 1926 |
| 103 | Spring in a Small Town | 1948 | Mu Fei | 1952 |
| 104 | Leave Her to Heaven | 1945 | John M. Stahl | 1954 |
| 105 | Le Corbeau | 1943 | Henri-Georges Clouzot | 1959 |
| 106 | Ball of Fire | 1941 | Howard Hawks | 1960 |
| 107 | La Terra Trema | 1948 | Luchino Visconti | 1961 |
| 108 | Cabin in the Sky | 1943 | Vincente Minnelli | 1970 |
| 109 | All the King's Men | 1949 | Robert Rossen | 2001 |
| 110 | In Which We Serve | 1942 | Noël Coward and David Lean | 2005 |
| 111 | Easter Parade | 1948 | Charles Walters | 2026 |
| 112 | Lifeboat | 1944 | Alfred Hitchcock | 2038 |
| 113 | High Sierra | 1940 | Raoul Walsh | 2044 |
| 114 | Brighton Rock | 1948 | John Boulting | 2048 |
| 115 | Sands of Iwo Jima | 1949 | Allan Dwan | 2055 |
| 116 | Stormy Weather | 1943 | Andrew L. Stone | 2076 |
| 117 | Spellbound | 1945 | Alfred Hitchcock | 2099 |
| 118 | Woman of the Year | 1942 | George Stevens | 2119 |
| 119 | Shoeshine | 1946 | Vittorio De Sica | 2120 |
| 120 | Hamlet | 1948 | Laurence Olivier | 2146 |
| 121 | Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein | 1948 | Charles Barton | 2220 |
| 122 | A Canterbury Tale | 1944 | Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger | 2300 |
| 123 | The Seventh Victim | 1943 | Mark Robson | 2314 |
| 124 | Hail the Conquering Hero | 1944 | Preston Sturges | 2340 |
| 125 | The Woman in the Window | 1944 | Fritz Lang | 2341 |
| 126 | Dance, Girl, Dance | 1940 | Dorothy Arzner | 2359 |
| 127 | Scarlet Street | 1945 | Fritz Lang | 2398 |
| 128 | The Uninvited | 1944 | Lewis Allen | 2410 |
| 129 | Tight Little Island | 1949 | Alexander Mackendrick | 2450 |
| 130 | Thirty Seconds over Tokyo | 1944 | Mervyn LeRoy | 2458 |
| 131 | The Little Foxes | 1941 | William Wyler | 2505 |
| 132 | The Picture of Dorian Gray | 1945 | Albert Lewin | 2507 |
| 133 | Fires Were Started | 1943 | Humphrey Jennings | 2537 |
| 134 | Heaven Can Wait | 1943 | Ernst Lubitsch | 2538 |
| 135 | The Naked City | 1948 | Jules Dassin | 2542 |
| 136 | The Letter | 1940 | William Wyler | 2543 |
| 137 | Listen to Britain | 1942 | Humphrey Jennings and Stewart McAllister | 2549 |
| 138 | Road to Morocco | 1942 | David Butler | 2561 |
| 139 | Suspicion | 1941 | Alfred Hitchcock | 2566 |
| 140 | Oliver Twist | 1948 | David Lean | 2579 |
| 141 | Unfaithfully Yours | 1948 | Preston Sturges | 2580 |
| 142 | A Letter to Three Wives | 1949 | Joseph L. Mankiewicz | 2602 |
| 143 | Anchors Aweigh | 1945 | George Sidney | 2651 |
| 144 | Body and Soul | 1947 | Robert Rossen | 2660 |
| 145 | Going My Way | 1944 | Leo McCarey | 2671 |
| 146 | Stray Dog | 1949 | Akira Kurosawa | 2684 |
| 147 | Holiday Inn | 1942 | Mark Sandrich | 2777 |
| 148 | The Spiral Staircase | 1946 | Robert Siodmak | 2784 |
| 149 | A Tree Grows in Brooklyn | 1945 | Elia Kazan | 2787 |
| 150 | D.O.A. | 1949 | Rudolph Maté | 2822 |
| 151 | Quai des Orfèvres | 1947 | Henri-Georges Clouzot | 2890 |
| 152 | Portrait of Jennie | 1948 | William Dieterle | 2939 |
| 153 | Caught | 1949 | Max Ophüls | 2984 |
| 154 | The Westerner | 1940 | William Wyler | 3005 |
| 155 | Story of G.I. Joe | 1945 | William A. Wellman | 3006 |