Home page All episodes sorted by rank All episodes sorted alphabetically All episodes sorted by writer All episodes sorted by director All episodes sorted by season Episodes with the most polarized opinions Episodes largely forgotten by fans Best and worst streaks of episodes An analysis of what makes episodes great Buffy writers sorted by the quality of their episodes Buffy directors sorted by the quality of their episodes Seasons of Buffy sorted by the quality of their episodes Buffy characters sorted by their possible contribution to episode quality Predicted episode quality based on writer, director, characters, and when aired Episodes that are much better or much worse than predicted Tastes in episodes Episodes ranked by taste Seasons ranked by taste Characters ranked by taste Writers ranked by taste Directors ranked by taste How the results on this site were obtained Ranking important contributors Reviews and Essays Frequently Asked Questions The links page Go to the sitemap

Best and Worst Writers

The writers below are ranked based on the average quality of their episodes after taking into account when the episodes aired. Only writers who wrote at least four episodes are in the list. Writers who wrote or co-wrote only one, two, or three episodes each are combined into the "Other Writers" category. Writers are given half credit for episodes that they co-write with another person except for "Doomed," for which each of the writers gets one-third credit. For the purposes of best and worst episode, writers get full credit / blame for solo and co-written episodes. Teams who write with each other exclusively are treated as if they are a single writer.

The number in parentheses can be thought of as being the "Joss bonus." It represents how many more points episode written by this person would get if it were written by Joss Whedon instead. Lower numbers suggest that the writer is almost as good as Joss Whedon. High numbers suggest that Joss Whedon could have done a much better job. By definition, Joss Whedon gets a 0 on this statistic. This interpretation assumes that the writer of the episode is the main cause of the episode's quality.

1. Joss Whedon (0.00)

Wrote 23.5 Episodes
Best Episode: "Once More, with Feeling" (121.50 points)
Worst Episode: "Ted" (62.72 points)

2. Drew Goddard (10.09)

Wrote 4 Episodes
Best Episode: "Conversations with Dead People" (89.39 points)
Worst Episode: "Never Leave Me" (66.16 points)

3. Other Writers (15.02)

Wrote 12 Episodes
Best Episode: "Passion" (Ty King: 99.05 points)
Worst Episode: "I, Robot You, Jane" (Ashley Gable & Thomas A. Swyden: 55.38 points)

4. David Greenwalt (16.11)

Wrote 7.5 Episodes
Best Episode: "Angel" (80.72 points)
Worst Episode: "Teacher's Pet" (57.26 points)

5. Marti Noxon (16.62)

Wrote 21.33 Episodes
Best Episode: "The Wish" (91.84 points)
Worst Episode: "Bad Eggs" (57.37 points)

6. Dean Batali & Rob Des Hotel (18.02)

Wrote 5 Episodes
Best Episode: "Phases" (67.09 points)
Worst Episode: "Never Kill A Boy on the First Date" (63.53 points)

7. Jane Espenson (18.24)

Wrote 19.33 Episodes
Best Episode: "Conversations with Dead People" (89.39 points)
Worst Episode: "Doublemeat Palace" (53.93 points)

8. Douglas Petrie (18.39)

Wrote 15 Episodes
Best Episode: "Fool for Love" (90.68 points)
Worst Episode: "As You Were" (60.54 points)

9. Rebecca Rand Kirshner (18.53)

Wrote 8 Episodes
Best Episode: "Tabula Rasa" (94.74 points)
Worst Episode: "Listening to Fear" (61.29 points)

10. Steven S. DeKnight (20.81)

Wrote 5 Episodes
Best Episode: "Seeing Red" (74.71 points)
Worst Episode: "All the Way" (61.62 points)

11. David Fury (21.08)

Wrote 14.33 Episodes
Best Episode: "Grave" (83.70 points)
Worst Episode: "Go Fish" (58.21 points)

12. Drew Z. Greenberg (22.52)

Wrote 6 Episodes
Best Episode: "Smashed" (68.16 points)
Worst Episode: "Empty Places" (63.15 points)

Conclusion

Overall, the writers account for 19.9% of episode quality.

This page was last modified on February 6, 2013